Writing Assignments 3 and 4

Paper Assignment #3

The Lincoln-Douglas Debates are today considered a seminal political event in American History. For this assignment, please chose one of the seven debates, and read the transcript. After completing that task, answer the following questions in a 4-5 page paper: What is the major point or points of contention between the two men at this particular debate? Which man had the more effective argument at this debate—and why is his argument more persuasive. Lastly, who “won” the debate that you chose? How can you tell?


Paper Assignment #4

Lincoln’s speech at the Cooper Union in New York City helped make him a viable presidential candidate in the eyes of many easterners. It is another instance of Lincoln using history to justify his core moral and political beliefs, as well. Using the transcript of the speech, and/or listening to a dramatic reading, answer the following questions: How does Lincoln use history in the instance to bolster his argument? Is this use similar to his use of history in his Peoria speech, or different. Explain those similarities and differences. Is his Cooper Union speech more or less persuasive than his Peoria speech? Why?

These assignment may be handed in together, or at two week intervals. You may choose to complete only one of the assignments, since there will be two more such assignments handed out before the end of the semester. The due dates are November 4 and November 18